Hello dear
Welcome To Tony's Pizza Shop
Tony's Pizza Shop, located at 36 Main St, Akron, NY, is a beloved local gem where consistency and quality reign supreme. Established as a community favorite, patrons like Jennifer Noble and Lee Bauer rave about the pizza and the standout fried dough, crafted with high-quality ingredients. Despite occasional longer wait times and a cash-only policy, visitors appreciate the welcoming staff and the unique square-cut pizzas. Notably, their medium wings receive accolades from discerning fans, including visitors from out of town. At Tony's, you’ll enjoy a fulfilling dining experience steeped in tradition, making each trip worth it.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Tony's Pizza Shop
Welcome to Tony's Pizza Shop, a beloved fixture in Akron, New York, where great food and warm memories intertwine. Nestled at 36 Main St, this charming eatery has been winning hearts and appetites for years, drawing in locals and visitors alike. With a strong reputation for consistency and quality, Tony's has become a staple for those seeking satisfying classic pizzeria fare.
One standout highlight at Tony's is their famed fried dough, as cherished by loyal customers like Jennifer Noble, who fondly recalls indulging in this treat since grade school. It’s a perfect companion to any meal and a must-try for newcomers. The delicious square cut pizza made a lasting impression on Socorro Berkland, who appreciated both the flavor and the friendly service even at closing time. The combination of crispy edges and hearty toppings creates a memorable experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
But let's not forget the famed medium wings, touted by Dave Szypulski as the best in Western New York. It's a testament to the culinary prowess of the kitchen, as they skillfully prepare these crowd-pleasers to perfection. Although Szypulski found the pizza satisfactory, his clear recommendation emphasizes the wings' superior standing in his culinary adventures. Pairing them with a crisp beverage at Tony's creates a dining experience that balances zest and comfort.
While some patrons, like Ronda Whitford, noted the prices can be on the higher side, the overall consensus remains positive. Most find that the quality ingredients and genuine customer care more than justify the cost. With cash-only transactions, Tony's Pizza Shop maintains a straightforward and accessible approach that mirrors its neighborhood charm.
In conclusion, Tony's Pizza Shop isn't just a place to grab a slice; it's a hub of community, where locals gather to share stories over satisfying dishes. Whether you're craving crispy wings, delightful fried dough, or a classic square-cut pizza, the warmth and familiarity found at Tony's will keep you coming back. So, if you find yourself in Akron, don't miss the chance to experience the culinary joy that is Tony's Pizza Shop.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Have been going to Tony’s since I was in grade school. Has always been consistent in their products. I especially love their fried dough! ”
“ The pizza was pretty good, everyone was happy with it. Was more expensive than we planned on. We were told an hour from the time we ordered on the phone, and it was longer than that but we waited comfortably. Would order here again because it was close by. Important Note: they accept cash only. ”
“ Ok, so I need to give you some context for this review. I am from Pittsburgh, my wife is from Akron. We live in Pittsburgh. Being together 13 years i have had pizza and wings from all over the Buffalo NY area when we visit family. With that being said I can say Tonys medium wings are the best in western NY, yes better than Anchor Bar and Duffs. When we visit Akron I have to have these wings! NOW with that said, here is the reality, they are very expensive, and their pizza is maybe average at best. My wife likes the calzones, i just want the wings. So in the end I cant reccomend the pizza, however the medium wings, and i stress medium, are the best around, expensive, yes, but well worth it in my opinion. ”
“ We drove to New York from PA n we stopped n tried their pizza. We absolutely loved it. ”
“ Tried their pizza for the first time yesterday and will definitely return again for another. It’s a family owned business that’s been around for a long time, the type I like to support. Fresh dough, a traditional pizza oven, and just the right amount of everything, prepared by hand. Also enjoyed my conversation with the polite gentleman that took my order and made the pizza. The best part is I fed my family without dirtying a plate at home for five dollars per person, with leftovers. Can’t beat that! ”
“ We came in close to closing time and they were so patient with us, even when we had problems with the atmosphere! Plus I love square cut pizza! thank you ”
“ Best pizza around! I would rather drive a few minutes further to get pizza that ALWAYS tastes great. Always worth the trip! Quality ingredients consistently ”